Steven Wu's Book Reviews
Author | Title | Rating | Latest

Glen Cook, Borges, Tolkien
February 10, 2002 (2:24 PM) ( link )

Reading continues slowly despite my other obligations. Recently I have been focusing on Glen Cook's The Black Company and Borges's Ficciones.

The Black Company has great atmosphere—not as good as Gene Wolfe's The Book of the New Sun, but compelling nonetheless. It's true, as I read in many reviews of this series, that the book focuses primarily (even claustrophobically) on everyday soldiers caught up in struggles too large for them to really comprehend. In The Black Company, the struggle seems to be between a group of powerful and evil wizards bent on destroying one another. Of course, each one is also subservient to a larger power—the Dominator and his Lady, whose roles I haven't yet quite figured out. And these greater powers have no qualms about using the men of the Black Company without regard for safety.

One benefit of this common-man approach to storytelling is that moments of awe are rare but inspiring. For instance, at one point the Black Company comes into contact with one of the evil wizards who are using them as pawns. Cook gives us this description.

It looked as tall as a house and half as wide. It wore scarlet bleached by time, moth-eaten, and tattered. It came up the street in a sort of shamble, now fast, now slow. Wild, stringy grey hair tangled around its head. Its bramble patch of a beard was so thick and matted with filth that its face was all but invisible. One pallid, liver-spotted hand clutched a pole of a staff that was a thing of beauty defiled by its bearer's touch. It was an immensely elongated female body, perfect in every detail. Someone whispered, "They say that was a real woman back during the Domination. They say she cheated on him."
Excellent. On the other hand, Cook's approach also means that, even halfway through the book, the plot feels aimless, meandering. With so little control over their own actions, the Black Company sort of moves from one mission to another without any real sense of purpose. Partly because of this, all of the characters also seem cold and slightly off—although this does contribute to the book's atmosphere.

Borges's Ficciones is still baffling as hell. So far I've read only two stories in it, each one about a fictional book. The stories are dense and confusing, written with a clearly erudite hand. I don't know if I like them.

I have a confession to make: although I should be reading new fiction (and even thesis books, every once in a while), I admit that I've taken to dipping into JRR Tolkien's The Fellowship of the Ring every once in a while over the past few days. It's such a comfort to read it—even if it's only a few pages at a time, I know immediately where I am, what just happened, and what is about to happen. So far I haven't even left the Shire yet, and it's astonishing to me how such an idyllic beginning can lead to the epic battles and dark forces that preoccupy the second and third books. Of course, those struggles are in part why the ending of the series—with the return to the Shire—strikes such a deep chord in me. Already I can feel myself tearing up in preparation for the last line of the book.

So that's that for reading. Hopefully I'll have a review of Cook's book up soon, and then maybe I'll have a few words to say about Borges. Will I review Fellowship? Well, what's the point? I'm giving it a 10 anyway. But we'll see.

Author | Title | Rating | Latest
Steven Wu's Book Reviews