Steven Wu's Book Reviews
Author | Title | Rating | Latest

September 2002

Back to Archives

New Review: CS Friedman's When True Night Falls
September 30, 2002 (12:06 PM) ( link )

ADDED a review of CS Friedman's When True Night Falls, the second book in The Coldfire Trilogy. It was ok. I guess I'll read the third book--which seems to be shorter than the other two--but it's not as though I'm much looking forward to it.

Indeed, rather than reading the third book immediately, I think I'll start reading The Deathgate Cycle, starting with the first book (whose name momentarily slips my mind). I'm a bit leery of getting started on a major fantasy series that may compel me to finish even if I don't like it (much like Friedman's books, actually), but The Deathgate Cycle comes with such high recommendations that I feel a little better about trying it out than I otherwise would.

In contrast to all of this uncertainty, Robin Hobb's Mad Ship is still great--it's good in all the ways that Ship of Magic was good, although, like the beginnings of many of Hobb's books, the going is a little slow. I'm getting a bit impatient with the pace of the whole series--I know that The Farseer Trilogy didn't really start picking up until the middle of the second book (after which it became a crazy rush to the end), but I sort of wish things would start speeding up in The Liveship Traders too. Plus, I want Malta to get it for being such a spoiled, annoying brat.


New Review: Robin Hobb's Ship of Magic
September 23, 2002 (11:35 AM) ( link )

ADDED a review of Robin Hobb's Ship of Magic. This is another great book in another great series. I've already started reading Mad Ship, the second book in The Liveship Traders Trilogy, and I hope to finish that by the end of the month.

I'm also trying to get through CS Friedman's When True Night Falls, but it's really no comparison to Hobb's series. What will be sad is if I end up reading the entire Liveship Traders Trilogy before finishing this second book (as I did with The Farseer Trilogy while I was trying to finish Black Sun Rising). But it's simply remarkable how much better Hobb's book is than Friedman's, although Hobb's has a much less exciting premise. (It makes me wonder what Hobb could have done with Friedman's world, but oh well.)

I think, because of all this, that The Deathgate Cycle will have to be put on hold. I also think that some time soon I'm going to just do some cleaning out of my Books I Plan to Read page; in particular I'd like to weed out stuff I don't really want to read anymore, as well as take out a lot of the descriptions and just have a list of books instead.

In other news, I'm considering whether or not to post a review of something completely different: John Hart Ely's book Democracy and Distrust: A Theory of Judicial Review. I read it for Con Law and it's interesting enough for me to try to discuss, but then, it doesn't really fit in with the rest of this page. But we'll see--if I do write up something anyway, I might as well try sticking Ely's book in as well.


Death Gate Cycle
September 16, 2002 (1:47 PM) ( link )

My friend Ali just gave me the first two books of Margaret Weis and Tracy Hickman's The Death Gate Cycle, promising that it would be a good read. The series is seven books long so I'm hoping it will be good enough to justify reading the entire thing. Ali did warn me, however, that she read them when she was a kid, and perhaps some of her love for these books comes from the fact that she was younger, more accepting, and more gullible (as we all were). But we'll see.

Reading continues fairly slowly, though one thing I've discovered is that I can actually read on a bus now (albeit with a slight queasy feeling still), making those long bus trips much easier to stomach. So I should be able to finish When True Night Falls soon, and then hopefully finish the Liveship Traders trilogy.


Ship of Magic, and other books
September 10, 2002 (3:57 PM) ( link )

Work at the law school has been keeping me busy most of the time. Although Yale has no grades, it's still tough to keep up with the reading--and since professors still expect active participation, there's a lot of pressure to still do the work.

As a result, my reading has suffered. CS Friedman's second book (When True Night Falls) is just as good/bad as the first book, which is not good news. But Robin Hobb's The Liveship Traders series, which begins with Ship of Magic, is fantastic--the first book is a little slow at times, but there were moments where I simply couldn't stop reading even with the prospect of an 8 a.m. class the next day. I'm glad to hear that Hobb actually has a third series out in the same universe--in fact, it re-visits FitzChivalry from the first trilogy--and I know that when I'm done with this trilogy I'm going out to find her third one too.

However I don't expect a great number of reviews this month as I figure out how best to balance my workload with my free time, especially given that I would like to see my friends, and my girlfriend. But I figure that after a year of work I deserve a break. (Heh.)


New Review: Michael Moorcock's Elric of Melnibone
September 3, 2002 (7:42 PM) ( link )

ADDED a review of Michael Moorcock's Elric of Melnibone. Light, frothy read. Don't do it unless you have a thing for semi-sentient evil swords with names like Stormbringer and Mournblade.

I recently discovered that Neil Gaiman's American Gods has won the 2002 Hugo Awards. Hm. As you know I didn't really like that book--and it definitely should not have won against China Mieville's Perdido Street Station (which was, shamefully, fifth place in the polls). After a Hugo for The Goblet of Fire last year (which was a good book, but not deserving of a Hugo), and now American Gods, I'm starting to lose my faith in the Hugos. Not that the Nebulas are any better, or the Top 100 Science Fiction list. I guess tastes vary too much for a large and diverse body of readers to agree on a canon that everybody likes, but that only makes reading more painful (especially since bad speculative fiction is really, really bad). Oh well--I've read enough stunners recently to restore my faith in the strengths of science fiction and fantasy as genres, so until I reach another dark streak of stinkers I'll just bite my tongue at where the awards go and keep on reading.


One-year anniversary and Top 10 list
September 2, 2002 (4:51 PM) ( link )

Today marks the one-year anniversary of this book-reviews page. In the past year I've read 73 books and 13 graphic novels, and written 102 reviews. This last month was the most prolific by far, with a total of 15 books read and 13 reviews written (I lumped all three Farseer books together in one review). Site visits also jumped up in the last month, with 127 hits coming from around the globe--totaling 1080 for the past year.

Now it's time for my much-promised Top 10 List. So, here it is:

Steven's Picks for
The Best Books of the Last Year
(that I read)


10. The Chronoliths, by Robert Charles Wilson
A great concept, deftly handled. This book was a huge improvement on Darwinia, which, in my humble opinion, sucked.

9. Lord of Light, by Roger Zelazny
Yet another great concept, and though the beginning is a little confusing I found it easy to grasp after a few chapters. I do have to warn you, though, that the story is a little slow; this book definitely appears on this list solely because the idea is so cool.

8. Jhereg, by Steven Brust
This book is total brain candy--no deep thoughts whatsoever, just lots of assassin fun. The rest of the books in the series lose much of the fun, smart-alecky approach of the first book, and suffer as a result. So just read this one.

7. Consider Phlebas, by Iain M. Banks
Also noteworthy: Player of Games, by the same author, which I liked a lot more. But Consider Phlebas deserves a spot on this list because it's so much fun to read--paging through it is like sitting through an action movie, and although I barely remember the larger plot I still remember most of the little action sequences inside. This is also on the list, rather than Player of Games, because I think the second book would be hard to stomach without at some some exposure to the Culture, which this first book provides.

6. Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep?, by Philip K Dick
I would be hard-pressed to explain what made this short novella so good. But it is.

5. Perdido Street Station, by China Mieville
Another novel jam-packed with great ideas, marred only by an inexplicably bad ending.

4. The Farseer Trilogy, by Robin Hobb
One of the single best fantasy series I have read in recent years. Unlike the books of other authors, like David Eddings, The Farseer Trilogy doesn't shy away from subjecting its characters to all sorts of (realistic) privations. A darkly fascinating read--in fact, I'm going to start reading her Liveship Traders Trilogy soon.

3. Bright Lights, Big City, by Jay McInerney
A short book, and the only mainstream novel on this list. But it was deeply moving and meaningful--a rare combination in a novel.

2. Bridge of Birds, by Barry Hughart
A joy from start to finish. No knowledge of or interest in China required--Hughart tells you everything you need to know (and a lot more, besides). The sequels aren't as good, and although I sort of liked Eight Skilled Gentlemen I don't think it was really worth it.

1. Doomsday Book, by Connie Willis
What a book this was--I remember being all depressed after reading it. Also noteworthy: Willis's To Say Nothing of the Dog, which is as funny as Doomsday Book is sad, and Passage, which is nowhere near as good as the other day but is still worth a read.

So there you have it--the ten best books I read in the last year. It was actually a little depressing making up this list: the top 8 are really the only books that I remember with great fondness, and the last two are here just to fill up the list. Let's hope the next year holds more, better books.

Back to Archives

Author | Title | Rating | Latest
Steven Wu's Book Reviews