Author | Title | Rating | Latest |
A book review by Steven Wu
http://www.scwu.com/bookreviews/
January 26, 2007
| Rating: 2 (of 10) |
As a formal matter there is nothing wrong with this setup. A diverse society, crammed into a pressure-cooker situation, and spiced with a mysterious arrival and hot, humanoid heavy breathing ("I prickled and throbbed under the dry wrap in response to his presence"): Connie Willis would have a field day. But McArthur doesn't pull it off. The story is, I gather, meant to be a science-fiction procedural, with Halley as the implausible private eye. (Doesn't she have a station to run?) But her investigation is too plodding, the prose too awkward, and the book -- at 450-plus pages! -- simply too long to generate much interest.
Copyright © 2007 Steven Wu
Steven Wu's Book Reviews |